Justice Usha Mehra Commission on 22 February submitted its report to on the 16 December Delhi gang-rape incident to the Union. held on were noted and approved by the Commission. Agenda Item No Recommendations of Justice Usha Mehra. Committee Report regarding. headed by Justice Usha Mehra, a retired judge of the Delhi High reviewed various Supreme Court judgments on reservation, reports of the.

Author: Shagor Fauzshura
Country: Mauritania
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Politics
Published (Last): 22 May 2010
Pages: 361
PDF File Size: 20.39 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.55 Mb
ISBN: 611-9-68217-446-9
Downloads: 24303
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Shakashura

No reasons were adduced for reducing the population of the Adi-andhras. Muniswamy pillai is out of context and the Commission ignored the very fact that the test for inclusion in the list of SCs is extreme social, educational and economic backwardness arising out of traditional practice of untouchability.

The report of the Commission is against the National Unity and Integrity. Hence there is no need or justification to divide the SCs which is not in the interests of the Country as a whole.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

Hence, usah conclusions drawn by the Commission are inaccurate and based on irrelevant and extraneous consideratons. Chennaiah’s case and to examine the Constitutional, Statutory and Legal ramifications.

It also failed to review the position of about 30, backlog vacancies which are not filled up in the State. The Malas and its allied castes boycotted the meetings held by the Commission and protested before the Commission during their visits and did not cooperate with the Commission.

Government Two government appointees in the law panel — then ex-offic Thus, further sub-classification, mini-classification, division or grouping is beyond the power of Parliament and thus unconstitutional. There are more than castes recognized as SCs in the Presidential List. While dealing with Madiga Dasu, it was observed that the Madiga Dasu accept food from all the communities except the Mala. Justice Usha Mehra Commission reports that there was an unanimous resolution by the State Legislature dated, 10 th December Justice usha mehra Commission is not a Statutory Commission appointed under any Law.

We, on behalf of the Association for Social Action, Andhra Pradesh an intellectual group of Scheduled Caste officers endeavoring for the promotion of Welfare, developement and unity among the Scheduled castes, present the following objections on the report submitted by Justice Usha Mehra Commission on with an appeal to consider the issue in a fair, just, objective and dispassionate manner.


The women – both officers and constables – will be deployed in each of the capital’s police stations and handle sensitive cases related to the fairer sex. The report of the Justice Usha Mehra Commission is perfunctory and incomplete as there was no basis on which particularly with reference to each caste were obtained and its authunticity is doubtful as there was no mention in the census format about sub-caste details.

Thus the suggested Remedy is worse than the Disease. Law Commission for “swift” scrapping of capital punishment 31 Aug, But, as per decennial growth rate, it should be TomorrowMakers Let’s get smarter about money.

Chinnaiah’s case wherein it was categorically said and held that the Parliament is only having a limited power of making exclusion or inclusion in the list and there is no power either to sub-divide or sub-classify or sub-group these castes and that the castes mentioned in the list to be members of one group for the purpose of the constitution and this group could not be sub-divided for any purpose. Government of India is concerned with the welfare of the SCs as a whole in the entire country.

The grouping of castes particularly with reference to Malas and Adi-andhras is incorrect. It is not clear and it is very ambiguous and bereft of necessary details. The Commission also failed to note and want only ignored the fact that B.

But, the Commission’s approach from inception appears that it had taken up the responsibility to categorise the SCs without proper application of mind and with a prejudice influenced by the political clout at the behest of the Hon’ble Minister for Social Justice and Empowerment and the Government of Andhra Pradesh which is espousing the cause of MRPS.

Hence, the report is inaccurate and inconsistent with the Census figures. While dealing with Malas, they were also referred to Adi-andhras. It is a deleberate attempt to show the population of Mala as much less to the population of the Madigas. Justice Usha Mehra Commission Report. Madiga is one caste among the castes. The observations of the Commission relating to Scheduled Caste in Andhra Pradesh are not correct and made with an ulterior motive.

The report of the Commission has been prepared with undue haste and with speed and submitted its report on In respect of Relli, it is stated that they do not take food or water from Mala, Madiga and Paky.

  AS9101 REV D PDF

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

Mehra Commission recommendations placed before Cabinet Sources said the Home Ministry has accepted several of the recommendations of the panel and these were placed before the Cabinet for final approval. The report of the Justice Mehra Commission is not only illegal, and unconstitutional but also opposed the judgement of the Supreme Court Constitutional bench in Dr.

It is admitted in the Commission report that Malas are also called as Adi-andhras. The very clause suggested by the Commission for amendment is not clear. It also includes the political purpose and their representations in Local Bodies, Municipalities, State Legislature and the Parliament. The report is purely advisory and not binding and need not be placed before the Legislature. The Commission also committed error in selecting a few institutions for sample study and a limited number of Government departments and agencies identified and selected by the Government which is out and out supporting the cause of MRPS.

The Commission except reiterating the guidelines issued by the Governent about the implementation of the Special Component Plan never bothered to review the implementation of the programme and failed to verify the diversion of funds made by the successive Governments in implementing the programmes.

The Commission’s observation about certain Scheduled Castes are contradictory to each other. Dec 31, The issue of Scheduled Castes is a National issue and the reservations are intended for constitutional purpose.

The Commission did not bother even to study the implications of the judgement nor discussed anywhere in the report about the findings of the Supreme Court and the remedies suggested by the Supreme Court. The opportunities depend upon factors like population, availability of schools, literacy and regional imbalances.


In respect of Mang, which is also a satellite caste of Madiga, they do not accept food and water from the Mala. Thus, the effort of the Commission to say that Scheduled Castes in Andhra Pradesh are heterogeneous is unconstitutional and unsustainable.

You won’t be able to use WhatsApp on these devices in